#1,033: There But For the Grace of G-d . . .
There but for the grace of G-d . . .
I swear by everything holy that the next time I hear a לאַנדסמאַן (lahtzmahn - Yiddish for, roughly “a fellow Jew”) proclaim that IT is “the best friend the Jewish people ever had,” I’m going to ברעכן (brechen - e.g. “vomit”) all ever the White House lawn. “Why?” you may well ask. Simply stated, he is the bipolar opposite of a friend or supporter. Whenever I ask what proof the person has for making such a statement, I regularly hear one or more of the following: “He moved the American Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem”; “He has provided more defense materiel to Israel than any other POTUS,” “How can he be anti-Semitic when his daughter, son-in-law and grandchildren are practicing Jews?”, and most recently, “No POTUS has ever focused more on punishing elite universities for being tolerant of anti-Semitic activities.”
Oy! We aren’t going to take the time or space to explain ITs motives behind most of these actions save, of course his daughter and her family, who, in accordance with the old dictum חזקת לאדם כשר (chezkat l’adam kashayr - Hebrew for “the presumption of being Jewish”) we will give a nod of acknowledgement. Otherwise what I’m hearing from this pro-MAGA folks is, what in Yiddish is called די זעלבע מיד אַלטע געשיכטע (di zelbe mid alte geshikhte - '“the same old tired story”).
The one area of ITs presidency I will touch upon is anti-Semitism. Although he certainly did not create the hatred which transcends most of human history, he has not outside of rhetorically - done a hell of a lot to confront of quell it. Much to the contrary, he has actually weaponized it. At this time of the year, when the Jewish calendar is book-ended by Purim and Passover when real antisemitism — and redemption from it — are top of mind for Jews, we would be wise to see Trump’s rhetoric and policies on antisemitism for what they really are: gaslighting that will further endanger American Jews.
By publicly linking federal funding for research to combating antisemitism — and cynically appropriating the Hebrew word “shalom” to announce ICE’s arrest of Mahmoud Khalil — Trump has actually fed nasty tropes about Jews wielding financial leverage and pulling the strings of government to protect perceived “Jewish” interests. Meanwhile, the Departments of Justice and Education (or what’s left of it) have launched antisemitism investigations into dozens of universities nationwide, singling out Jews as worthy of federal protection while simultaneously dismantling diversity, equity and inclusion efforts that support countless vulnerable and underprivileged Americans. In other words, for IT, the concern about the horrific rise in anti-Semitic acts isn’t a project; it’s a pretext.
Sometime in the early hours of Sunday, April 13 - the first day of Passover - the Pennsylvania governor’s mansion was set on fire by an arsonist while Governor Josh Shapiro and his family slept inside. Ironically, the greatest damage occurred in the very room (see photo above) in which the governor, his wife Lori, their 4 children and other family members had partaken in the traditional Passover seder. There but for the grace of G-d they escaped harm. When arrested on charges of terrorism, attempted murder aggravated arson and aggravated assault, the alleged arsonist, 38-year old Cody Allen Balmer told police that he used two Molotov cocktails to set the residence on fire. According to authorities, Balmer told them that he had also brought a small sledgehammer with him for the purpose of killing Governor Shapiro had he encountered him. Balmer, who actually had turned himself in to state authorities, said he attacked the mansion because of Governor Shapiro’s stance on the war in Gaza and that “needs to know that he will not take part in his plans for what he wants to do to the Palestinian people.”
Exactly how the murder of a Jewish Governor and his family (the alleged perpetrator’s stated intent) could save Palestinian lives half a world away is anyone’s guess. Fortunately, many Republicans, including V.P. Vance, A.G. Pam Bondi and Freedom Caucus Chair Scott Perry issued statements deploring the arson attack, calling it, variously, “inexcusable,” “deeply disturbing” and “horrifying.” Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., said, “Political violence of any kind is never acceptable, and it is especially unconscionable to attack a Jewish family during the first night of Passover.”
Rep. Dan Meuser, R-PA
Not all responses were so mixed with angst over, concern about and condemnation of the attack. Republican Rep. Dan Meuser (Penn.), a potential challenger to Josh Shapiro in the 2026 gubernatorial race, suggested that .Shapiro was “asking for it” when an attacker burned down part of his house after his Passover celebration and that he needs to “tone it down” with actions against President Donald Trump. “This guy is a psycho of course,” Meuser said of the attacker during an appearance on a local radio show on Tuesday, April 15. “And our hearts go out to the Shapiro family on this. But you know, they’ve got to tone it down, too. I mean, every action Josh Shapiro has taken so far against the president has either been a lawsuit or a falsehood.”
When asked for his response to the crime, IT, who, during his last campaign referred to Shapiro as a “highly overrated Jewish Governor [who] has done nothing for Israel and never will” said that he “wasn’t aware of a motive for the man accused of setting the fire,” and sloughed it off as nothing more than being the act of someone who was “probably just a whack job.” As of today, IT has yet to issue a public statement or contact Governor Shapiro about the arson attack. When Jonathan Martin, senior political columnist at Politico criticized IT for staying silent (except for his “whack job” comment) after the Passover blaze, he was faced with quite a bit of backlash from conservatives online, many stating that when IT was the target of an assassination attempt at a Butler, Pennsylvania campaign rally on July 13, 2024, Shapiro did not contact their standard bearer. (n.b. in truth, before thatday was out, Shapiro’s office issued a heartfelt statement wishing the then-former President a speedy recovery while condemning the attack and mourning the death of former firefighter Corey Comperatore, a native Pennsylvanian).
Eerily, Its “whack job” response came during a quicky presser held in the Oval Office with the president of El Salvador, one of this hemisphere’s most brutal dictators. (n.b.: It never ceases to amaze me that IT, who is forever yakking about taking over the Panama Canal, making Canada the 51st State and turning Greenland into the newest American territory [à la American Samoa, Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands and Guam] claims he doesn’t have the power to get Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele to send back the more than 200 men illegally kidnapped and currently residing in this hemisphere’s most notorious mega-prison, Centro de Confinamiento del Terrorismo [CECOT]).
We conclude with two thoughts: one for the POTUS, the other for/about the Shapiro family.
First for POTUS: From time to time, I am angrily attacked by readers wanting to know why I never say anything nice about the man they consider to be the best president in the history of the United States. I’ve given this a bit of thought, and have concluded that there is one very nice thing I can write about him:
Donald Trump is mortal!
And second, a thought for the Shapiro family: In the Jewish world, when someone - or a group, like a family - survive a traumatic, potentially life-threatening episode, it is customary. to recite a blessing known as Birkat Hagomel, which goes:
בָּרוּךְ אַתָּה הׇ אֱלֹהֵינוּ מֶלֶךְ הָעוֹלָם הַגּוֹמֵל לְחַיָּבִים טוֹבוֹת שֶׁגְּמָלַנִי כָּל טוֹב
namely,
“Blessed are You, O G-d. ruling spirit of the universe, Who rewards the undeserving with goodness, and rewarded me (us) with goodness.”
To which we, who have heard them say this prayer. respond
אָמֵן מִי שֶׁגְמָלְךָ כָּל טוֹב הוּא יִגְמָלְךָ כָּל טוֹב סֶלָה
namely:
”Amen. May the One who rewarded you with all goodness, continue to reward you with only goodness, Selah!”
Copyright©2025 Kurt Franklin Stone